Open Access

Lucas Mignien, Stefan Stoll

• Hydrological variability is a key factor in structuring biotic and abiotic processes in river ecosystems and is of particular importance to fish populations. We used 171 hydrological indices (HI) and young-of-the-year (YOY) fish abundances as indicators of reproductive success to compare species' response patterns to high and low flows on short-, intermediate-, and long-term scales. Our study included 13 common fish species in headwater streams of North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany. Generalized linear models using YOY abundances and HI on high- and low-flow patterns explained on average 64 % of the variability. HI calculated from long time series worked better than HI describing short- and intermediate-term high- and low flows. Species' reproductive success response to low flow HI depended on specific ecological traits whereas high flow HI differentially affected species according to their life history strategies. Equilibrium strategists responded negatively to high frequency and magnitude along with late timing of high flow, while periodic and opportunistic species mostly thrived under these conditions. We identified four species traits that mediated these differences between life history strategies. The reproductive success of species with low relative fecundity, large eggs and larvae, and long incubation periods was negatively impacted by the high frequency, high magnitude, and late timing of high flows. Conversely, the reproductive success of species with high relative fecundity, short incubation periods and small eggs and larvae was fostered by strong, frequent, and late high flows. The consideration of the relationship between reproductive success, life history, and fish species traits over several years under a range of flows is a novel step towards the implementation of measures to mitigate negative impacts and enhance conditions for successful fish reproduction.